Effects of Temperature and Niclosamide on the Toxicity of the Lampricide TFM (3-trifluoromethyl-4-nitrophenol) to Sea Lamprey (Petromyzon marinus) and Rainbow Trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss)
Loading...
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
University of Waterloo
Abstract
The pesticide TFM (3-trifluoromethyl-4’-nitrophenol) is applied to rivers and streams that drain into the Laurentian Great Lakes to control populations of blood-feeding invasive sea lamprey (Petromyzon marinus), which continue to threaten its fisheries. Targeting larval sea lamprey, TFM impairs mitochondrial ATP production by uncoupling oxidative phosphorylation, leading to eventual energy depletion and death. TFM selectivity stems from the limited capacity of sea lamprey to detoxify the lampricide. In contrast, non-target fishes such as rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) more efficiently detoxify TFM into more hydrophilic, readily excreted metabolites. TFM toxicity is affected by environmental factors such as pH and alkalinity, which alter the chemical speciation of TFM and its bioavailability. Water temperature also influences TFM toxicity, with larval TFM tolerance increasing at warmer temperatures, but the underlying mechanisms have not yet been resolved. During field treatments, TFM is often used in combination with niclosamide at 0.5-2.0% (w/w), which reduces the TFM concentrations required to eliminate 99.9% (12-h LC99.9) of larval sea lamprey by up to 40%, though the mechanism(s) of these interactions have not been resolved. This thesis therefore asked how water temperature or co-exposure to niclosamide alters TFM toxicity in sea lamprey relative to the non-target rainbow trout, and whether these effects can be explained by corresponding changes in detoxification capacity.
To test the hypothesis that an increased capacity to eliminate TFM explained the greater TFM tolerance in sea lamprey at warmer temperatures (Chapter 2), larvae were exposed to TFM over a range of temperatures, and liver and muscle were collected for TFM quantification. In sea lamprey, the 12-h LC50 of TFM increased steadily (~1.5-fold) as water temperature rose from 7°C to 28°C. When exposed to a common TFM concentration across temperatures, liver and muscle TFM concentrations were lowest in lamprey acclimated to 24°C, consistent with greater detoxification capacity at warmer temperatures. In contrast, toxicity was biphasic in rainbow trout exposed to TFM at 6-21°C (Chapter 4), with greatest tolerance at 6°C and 21°C, where the 12-h LC50 values were highest at intermediate temperatures of 11°C and 16°C. However, the effects of temperature on trout TFM tolerance were relatively small, with only a 30% difference between maximum and minimum 12-h LC50 values, compared to sea lamprey, in which the 12-h LC50 value increased by 150% between 7°C and 28°C. Notably, tissue TFM accumulation in trout was highest at 21°C, indicating that TFM toxicity in rainbow trout, unlike in sea lamprey, is not directly tied to detoxification capacity but instead reflects interactions among multiple physiological processes. These findings indicate that water temperature, alongside water pH and alkalinity, should be considered when determining TFM application concentrations to optimize treatment efficacy and minimize non-target species risks.
Applications of TFM are regularly supplemented with 0.5-2.0% niclosamide (w/w), which substantially improves TFM efficacy. The concentration addition model was used to characterize the nature of TFM: niclosamide interactions using the toxic unit (TU) concept, in which 1TU = the 12-h LC50 of each chemical. Exposure of larval sea lamprey to TFM/1% niclosamide mixtures (Chapter 3) resulted in synergistic (greater than additive) interactions when the sum of TFM plus niclosamide (TUTot Exp) exceeded 1TU. However, interactions were antagonistic (less than additive) when the TUTot Exp were less than 1TU, indicating a concentration-dependent shift in the nature of TFM/niclosamide interactions. Elevated TFM toxicity in the presence of niclosamide corresponded with greater TFM accumulation in the muscle but not in the liver, consistent with impaired hepatic metabolism of TFM by niclosamide. In rainbow trout (Chapter 5), the TFM/1% niclosamide mixture produced antagonistic interactions (< 50% mortality) across all concentrations tested. Co-exposure of the trout to TFM and niclosamide led to greater TFM accumulation in liver and brain, was consistent with competitive inhibition of enzymatically mediated detoxification by the liver. These divergent tissue-distribution patterns may indicate species-specific mechanisms underlying TFM toxicity and how toxicity is modified by niclosamide.
In conclusion, this thesis demonstrates that TFM toxicity is governed by water temperature in addition to pH and alkalinity. Thus, temperature is another abiotic variable that should be considered when planning and executing lampricide applications. Evidence was also provided that indicates that niclosamide interferes with TFM detoxification, accounting for enhanced toxicity to sea lamprey, trout and likely other non-target organisms when exposed to TFM/niclosamide mixtures. However, species-specific differences in modes of TFM handling and detoxification need to be further elucidated between sea lamprey, trout, and other species. The improved mechanistic understanding generated by this research provides a foundation for more precise, evidence-based tailoring of lampricide treatments to prevailing environmental conditions. Thus, this thesis will help move the Sea Lamprey Control Program toward improved treatment efficacy, reduced chemical use and cost, and minimized effects on non-target species. More broadly, this work offers a framework for understanding how environmental conditions and chemical mixtures influence the toxicity of other phenolic compounds in other aquatic organisms in the environment.