UWSpace is currently experiencing technical difficulties resulting from its recent migration to a new version of its software. These technical issues are not affecting the submission and browse features of the site. UWaterloo community members may continue submitting items to UWSpace. We apologize for the inconvenience, and are actively working to resolve these technical issues.
 

Graveyard of Republics: An Analysis of Torture in Counterinsurgency

Thumbnail Image

Files

Howey_James.pdf (584.78 KB)

Date

2021-09-20

Authors

Howey, James

Journal Title

Journal ISSN

Volume Title

Publisher

University of Waterloo

Abstract

Counterinsurgency relies on the dual instruments of propaganda and coercion. If well balanced, these instruments may convince the civilian populace that the rebels cannot win; furthermore, the agenda of counterinsurgents seems to be morally superior to that of the rebels. To attain this balance, counterinsurgents must have a steady flow of intelligence. This is a key to victory, but intelligence gathering is a complex and time-consuming process. In times of great pressure, counterinsurgents tend to fall back on brutality, including torture, to compensate for a lack of information. Although torture provides a great volume of information, the cost of its acquisition is enormous: torture cripples pacification efforts, as it alienates the civilian populace and boosts insurgency. Furthermore, the credibility of information gained via torture is uncertain. The French campaign in Algeria and the American Global War on Terror were lost in part because security agencies resorted to torture in order to gain vital intelligence. The poison pill of torture is inimical to rational counterinsurgency operations.

Description

Keywords

torture, counterinsurgency, enhanced interrogation techniques, black sites, UNCAT, GWOT, Geneva Convention, United Nations Convention Against Torture, United States of America, France, Algeria, Abu Ghraib, Battle of Algiers, Iraq, Afghanistan, Global War on Terror, International Stabilization Assistance Force, ISAF, North Atlantic Treaty Organization, NATO, Central Intelligence Agency, CIA, Federal Bureau of Investigation, FBI, Alberto Gonzales, George W. Bush, Charles de Gaulle, Coalition of the Willing, Poland, Rendition, interrogation, COIN, asymmetric warfare, war, conflict, warfare, EIT, Rendition Detention Interrogation, RDI, Improvised Explosive Device, IED, terrorism, Al-Qaeda, AQ, Al-Qaeda in Iraq, AQI, Taliban, Iraqi Insurgency, Saddam Hussein, Revolution in Military Affairs, RMA, counter insurgency, insurgency, War on Terror, waterboarding, Khalid Sheik Mohammad, KSM

LC Keywords

Citation

URI

http://hdl.handle.net/10012/17418

Collections

Theses
History