The Influence of Goal-Orientation on Parent-Child Affect During a Problem-Solving Task
Loading...
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
University of Waterloo
Abstract
Background. When children experience positive affect, their attentional frame is broadened, building flexible thinking. During collaborative activities with parents, there are opportunities for children to express positive affect. However, parental goal orientation may influence whether both parents and children express or elicit positive affect. Understanding how parental goal-orientation influences individual and shared expressions of parent and child affect may provide novel insights into how dyadic affective dynamics support early learning.
Objectives. The goal of this study was to 1) examine the association between parents’ goal orientation (process versus outcome) and the frequency of a parent’s own, and their child’s, affect expressions (positive, negative, and neutral), and 2) examine the relation between parental goal orientation (process versus outcome) and the frequency of instances of shared positive affect within the dyad. It was hypothesized that when parents were assigned to a process-oriented condition, both parents and children would express more positive affect, less negative affect, and at the level of the dyad increased instances of shared positive affect, relative to parents and children in an outcome-oriented condition.
Methods. Data were leveraged from a larger study examining parents’ goal orientation, joint attention, and dyadic interactions (N = 160; 80 dyads; child Mage = 4.43). Parents were randomly assigned to a process (“focus on your child’s learning experience”) or an outcome (“focus on getting the puzzles done”) oriented condition before working on a series of puzzles for eight minutes. Parent and child affect were coded second by second using Mangold INTERACT software.
Results. Across conditions, both parents and children demonstrated predominantly neutral affect (i.e., > 80%) while they worked on the task, F(2, 156) = 8363.31, p < .001. However, a significant three-way interaction between condition, role, and affect emerged, F(2, 156) = 4.50, p = .013. Follow-up analyses showed that parents expressed significantly more positive affect than children, but only in the outcome-oriented condition. Consistent with the findings at the level of the individual, dyads displayed comparable and limited instances of shared positive affect in both the process-oriented (M = 1.95%) and outcome-oriented (M = 1.57%) conditions as dyads spent the vast majority of their time in a state of shared neutral affect.
Implications. This study highlights the role of parental goal-orientation on affective exchanges within parent-child interactions and suggests that an outcome-oriented approach may be associated with slight increases in parents’ positive affect expressions relative to the child, during learning tasks. However, there was limited power to detect these effects given the extremely low frequency of any positive expressions during the learning task. Alternate analytic methods, such as temporal analyses examining sequences of shifts between neutral, positive, and negative affect between parents and children, may provide more information about the associations between parent goal-orientations, dyad affective exchanges, and children’s early learning.