Metal Concentrations in an Arctic Wastewater Wetland: Insights and Innovations from Baker Lake, Nunavut, Canada

Abstract

The unique climatic conditions and isolated geographies of Arctic communities present distinct challenges for municipal wastewater treatment. Most communities depend on natural wetlands to provide passive treatment of wastewater; however, increased pressure on these systems from prolonged use, climate change, and intensifying human activity has resulted in the recent development of northern-specific standards for wastewater. These standards, among other objectives, aim to maintain healthy fish populations and diverse aquatic ecosystems, while calling for community consultation, integration of traditional knowledge, and adherence to federal and territorial regulations. A passive wastewater treatment system near Baker Lake, NU, served as a case study to address knowledge gaps regarding ecosystem function and trace metal dynamics in abiotic and biotic ecosystem compartments subject to wastewater inputs. Additionally, this research explored a method for time-resolved analysis of contaminant histories, which is particularly valuable in environments lacking baseline data or where regular monitoring is challenging, including in the Arctic.

Between the summers of 2019 and 2021, a series of lakes that represented wastewater-affected and reference systems were sampled for water, sediment, and fish. Water from wastewater-affected lakes had elevated concentrations of metals (e.g., Mn, Fe, Cu) and increased primary productivity (as inferred from chlorophyll-a concentrations), with persistent hypereutrophic conditions; extremely low dissolved oxygen levels were recorded in the lake closest to wastewater influent. Although sediment analysis near wastewater sources indicated higher levels of Cu and Zn, overall sediment chemistry was similar across all sites. The influence of wastewater on the trophic ecology of Burbot (Lota lota) was minimal, whereas Arctic grayling (Thymallus arcticus) had more enriched (i.e., less negative) δ13C at wastewater-affected sites, suggesting altered energy pathways in lakes that receive nutrients from wastewater. Analyses of metals in muscle tissue revealed lower, although not significant, concentrations of methylmercury – the toxic, biomagnifying form of mercury - in fish from wastewater-affected sites compared to those from reference sites. These lower concentrations of methylmercury in fish muscle tissue occurred despite higher concentrations in abiotic media, potentially because of somatic growth dilution, but more research is necessary. Analyses of trace metals in otoliths revealed distinct multi-element otolith signatures (i.e., Zn, Mn, Cu, Fe, and Pb) between wastewater-affected and reference lakes, and significantly greater concentrations of Fe in a lake receiving wastewater across two reconstructed periods of growth. Together, findings from this research not only fill knowledge gaps regarding the influence of municipal wastewater on cold, oligotrophic freshwater systems in the subarctic, but also highlight the potential uses and limitations of otoliths as markers of wastewater exposures.