The Promise and the Practice of Digital Participatory Planning
Loading...
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
University of Waterloo
Abstract
Communications technologies and digital platforms now structure significant portions of citizen–planner interactions. Over the past decade, a new class of participation software has emerged as routine infrastructure for public engagement in local planning. Dedicated Digital Engagement Platforms (DDEPs) are purpose-built, multifunctional online hubs, offered primarily through software-as-a-service models by for-profit vendors, that consolidate a municipality’s digital engagement efforts into a single interactive environment. DDEPs power many local governments’ “Have-Your-Say” websites, providing a centralized space where residents learn about municipal projects, answer surveys, pin comments on maps, and share ideas. Despite their rapid and widespread adoption, this unique class of software has received little dedicated attention in planning scholarship. The critical theoretical lenses that have enriched our understanding of participation more broadly—particularly agonistic critique and postpolitical analysis—have not been brought to bear on these digital tools. This dissertation characterizes, explores, and critically scrutinizes the use of DDEPs in Canadian municipal planning. It is guided by a general question: what is the role of the most recent innovations in digital engagement tools in addressing, or contributing to, the identified shortcomings of participatory planning processes? The research proceeds through three journal-length manuscripts that move from empirical documentation through practitioner experience to critical theoretical analysis. The first paper defines DDEPs and documents the extent of their adoption through a nationwide scan of 839 Canadian municipalities, revealing that a majority of Canadians now reside in a jurisdiction served by a DDEP, with the market overwhelmingly consolidated around a single commercial provider. The second paper draws on semi-structured interviews with 44 professionals responsible for procuring and administering these platforms across 33 municipalities and three platform vendors. Applying a four-part platformization framework developed for this study, it reveals how a mix of rapid adoption, shallow deployment, and tightly managed online spaces risks a kind of performative handwaving of participatory process. The third paper brings a postpolitical lens to the same practitioner accounts, diagnosing how platform architecture and administrative practice together constitute depoliticization through three interconnected mechanisms: the scoping and control of dialogue, the sanitization of dissent, and the performance of openness. Taken together, the three papers establish a cumulative argument that DDEPs function as postpolitical infrastructures—platforms whose embedded logics of order, standardization, manageability, and metrics align with and accelerate the depoliticizing tendencies that critical scholars have long identified in consensus-oriented participatory governance. The digital turn in participatory planning, as it has unfolded in Canadian municipalities, has encoded the recognized deficiencies of communicative approaches into the default architecture of digital participation. In connecting platformization theory and postpolitical critique to digital engagement scholarship in ways that existing literature has not, this dissertation identifies what I term a deliberative antipattern, through which digital participatory planning scholarship and platform adoption have replicated rather than interrogated the limitations of communicative planning. The dissertation also offers planners and engagement professionals a conceptual vocabulary for recognizing what is at stake in the routine administrative choices that configure digital participation and argues that because postpolitical conditions are produced through specific, identifiable mechanisms, they can also be contested.