Global-Archaic Cities: Nationalist, Nostalgic Mutations of the Global City
Loading...
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
University of Waterloo
Abstract
In the past decade and a half, a small but growing cluster of urban megaprojects have hybridized the rhetoric and aesthetics of neoliberal globalization with contrary narratives of rebuilding lost national monuments or urban landscapes to return to a mythical past. This thesis gives this phenomenon a name — the global-archaic city — and examines the strategic motivations for and urban consequences of hybridizing two narratives and models of city building that appear so contradictory.
The thesis first surveys separately the two constituent elements of the global-archaic city: the global city trope (and its associated globalization narratives) and national mythscapes (and their associated narratives of rebuilding and return). Then, in three case studies of contemporary urban megaprojects, the thesis demonstrates how global-archaic cities hybridize these opposite geographic and historical imaginaries into anachronistic urban landscapes and bidirectional narratives of national restoration through globalization.
The thesis suggests understanding the global-archaic city as a post-2008 mutation of the global city trope. In response to neoliberal globalization’s crisis of legitimacy, global-archaic cities preserve the economic base of globalization while substituting the superstructure of cultural globalization for localist nostalgia. This seemingly benign shift in legitimizing rhetoric, however, has unexpected material consequences by creating incentives within the logic of neoliberal globalization to simulate the resurrection of historical urban geographies and landscapes.