Older but not Younger Children Distinguish between Ability and Proximity-Based Close Counterfactuals
Loading...
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
University of Waterloo
Abstract
Counterfactuals are events that could have happened but did not. This study examined whether children (4-7-years-old, N = 408) understand close counterfactuals based on proximity (e.g., “He almost won the race”) and those based on ability (e.g., “He easily could have won the draw”). Children saw a race between three animals where the fastest lost (e.g., cheetah), one of the two slower animals won (e.g., sheep) and the other was just behind (e.g., pig). They were then asked which animal was counterfactually close to winning in terms of proximity or ability. In Experiment 1, they were either asked which animal almost or easily could have won and in Experiment 2 they were either asked which animal almost or should have won. In Experiment 3, we added a fourth animal which tied for last with the fastest animal and explained that the animals in last place suffered a mishap while racing. Children were asked which animal almost won, easily could have won, wants to race again most, and will still be sad tomorrow. Children showed an understanding of proximity-based counterfactual closeness starting at 4-years-old, consistently identifying the second-place animal as the one who almost won. In contrast, only older children showed an understanding of ability-based counterfactuals. Older children mostly identified the fastest animal as the one who easily could have or should have won. This suggests a developmental gap where younger children recognize proximity but not ability-based counterfactual closeness.