Coagulant addition for managing sediment-associated phosphorus bioavailability to prevent cyanobacterial blooms in drinking water reservoirs
MetadataShow full item record
To ensure the uninterrupted supply of adequate amounts of drinking water, many utilities rely on reservoirs for raw (i.e., untreated) water storage prior to treatment. For example, reservoirs are integral to storing water originating as mountain snowpack that melts and slowly releases water to downstream rivers and lakes, serving ~75% of the western United States and Canada and approximately two billion people globally. Although raw water supply reservoirs have been historically managed for water quantity, not quality, reservoir management objectives are rapidly evolving. The importance of reservoir management for source quality is increasing as the relationships between source water quality, treatment costs, finished water quality, and public health protection are better understood, and climate change-exacerbated pressures on that relationship are better described. Water supply reservoir management is increasingly recognized as an integral component of risk management in the water industry due to the inextricable connection of climate change to source water quality and treatment costs, finished water quality, and public health protection. Multipurpose reservoirs frequently provide seasonal flow equalization, storage during periods of high precipitation (i.e., rain, snow melt), hydroelectric power, and flood mitigation; they also ensure that demand can be met during low flow periods and droughts. Notably, reservoirs are not typically managed for influxes of fine sediment and associated nutrients, which are more frequent in many areas because of climate change-exacerbated landscape disturbances such as wildfires and extreme precipitation. Algae, especially cyanobacteria, blooms are one of the biggest threats to water quality and the provision of safe drinking water globally. High densities of algal cells have the potential to lead to customer complaints, service disruptions, and even outages, especially in water treatment plants lacking advanced treatment options. Phosphorus (P) is the limiting nutrient for primary productivity in freshwater. Fine sediment is the primary vector of phosphorus transport in aquatic systems, thus fine sediment management to mitigate or prevent releases of bioavailable P to the water column could be integrated into water treatment operations, potentially as a climate change adaptation strategy. Drinking water reservoirs are not typically designed to manage internal loading of phosphorus; while this has been well studied in lakes, investigations of management strategies such as coagulant addition to prevent phosphorus release from bottom sediments (i.e., phosphorus inactivation) to mitigate the proliferation of cyanobacteria in raw water storage reservoirs are scant. Here, a series of lab- and field-scale analyses were conducted to (i) describe phosphorus release from fine sediment in a raw water reservoir, (ii) characterize its availability for biological uptake, (iii) evaluate phosphorus inactivation by application of common coagulants (FeCl3, alum, PACl), and (iv) evaluate the combination of strategically-timed reservoir dredging and coagulant application on phosphorus inactivation and turbidity reduction. This study demonstrated that significant amounts of phosphorus were readily released from fine sediment in the study reservoir, suggesting the need for fine sediment management. Application of typical doses of common chemical coagulants, especially FeCl3 effectively inactivated phosphorus to below target thresholds in the presence of fine sediment, as would be expected. Moreover, the combination of reservoir dredging and coagulant application during higher algae risk periods not only inactivated phosphorus, but also eliminated the potential for its re-release to the reservoir water column with the concurrent benefit of turbidity reduction. Thus, this study demonstrated that seasonal coagulant application coupled with strategically-timed reservoir dredging may offer utilities reliant on offline raw water storage reservoirs an effective P inactivation approach for risk management and climate change adaptation.
Cite this version of the work
Nikolas Knezic (2021). Coagulant addition for managing sediment-associated phosphorus bioavailability to prevent cyanobacterial blooms in drinking water reservoirs. UWSpace. http://hdl.handle.net/10012/17276
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Diagnosing the role of non-water factors in water governance situations: assessing the external governance of water Alvarado Revilla, Fabiola (University of Waterloo, 2021-02-26)The issue of the scale at which water governance should be organized to best address water challenges is one of the main ongoing debates in the literature. Traditionally, governance of water problems has been approached ...
Exploring the Implementation Potential of a Proposed Water Ethic: A Canadian Case Study into Underlying Ethical Considerations for Water Resources Management Matthews, Cushla (University of Waterloo, 2013-01-25)Ideas about water use and ethics have been linked for many thousands of years. In this millennium, water resources remain a primary area of concern throughout the world, including such issues as shortages, supply, flooding, ...
Proposing A Water Ethic: A Comparative Analysis of <em>Water for Life: Alberta's Strategy for Sustainability</em> Beveridge, Meghan (University of Waterloo, 2006)Because water is basic to life, an ethical dimension persists in every decision related to water. By explicitly revealing the ethical ideas underlying water-related decisions, human society's relationship with water, and ...